Briefly shows a rare, vulnerable side regarding her past, revealing that she values the pillowcase more than the expensive new gift.
Thinking she's doing a favor, Caroline donates Max's old, worn-out sheets to charity. However, she quickly learns that Max’s old pillowcase was the only sentimental item Max had left from her difficult childhood. This leads to a frantic, comedic mission to retrieve the bedding from a donation bin, which has since been claimed as a home by a local homeless man.
After finding themselves with a little extra cash, Caroline decides to splurge. Guilt-ridden after spending joint funds on high-end hair extensions for herself, she tries to "make it right" by buying Max a brand-new bedding set.