The investigation uncovers that Michael Elkins was a chronically abusive father. The "ritual" elements at the crime scene were a staged attempt by Michael to deflect suspicion onto the local witch and protect his reputation. Michael eventually confesses, claiming he killed Cody in "self-defense" after the boy attacked him while trying to protect his younger brother, Brad, from further abuse. Key Character Moments
Provides comic relief through his unexpected superstition. Despite his stoic nature, he is genuinely unnerved by Tamzin Dove's "magic," leading Jane to give him a "protective" jar of ashes at the end of the episode to put his mind at ease. [S1E12] Red Rum
Through a characteristic "mentalist trap," Jane leads the true killer to expose themselves. He convinces the town that Tamzin has cast a "spell of revelation" that will draw the murder weapon back to its owner. During a late-night stakeout, Jane and Lisbon catch Cody's father, , attempting to bury the murder weapon—a large wrench—in the woods. The Big Reveal The investigation uncovers that Michael Elkins was a