If you prefer your ice cream served with a side of theatricality or vintage charm: Brooker’s Founding Flavors Ice Cream

Step back into the American Colonial era at this tavern-style shop. The staff wears , and the flavors are named after historical figures—so good they could "convince Thomas Jefferson to trade in his quill for a waffle cone". Amy's Ice Creams ClosedAustin, TX

A vibrant, and candy store that feels like a vintage circus. It’s a perfect spot for those seeking a heavy dose of nostalgia alongside their double scoop of black cherry. Creative Formats